Impairment Coverage Could Aid Lenders Hurt by Katrina
Raymond Reed is the chief underwriting officer of Lenpex, a Deans & Homer affiliated company. As a managing general underwriter, Lenpex provides insurance solutions and related consulting services to the mortgage lending industry.
Hurricane Katrina caused more flood and wind damage to property than any previous event in U.S. history. As chronicled in the media, many of the owners of the damaged properties do not have adequate insurance to make the necessary repairs. Not so well publicized is the fact that many lenders hold mortgages on those properties.
Aid from federal and local governments, as well as efforts made by lenders to keep homeowners in their homes, will no doubt have a major impact on the number of foreclosures. Unfortunately, however, there will still be much unrepaired damage and there will be many foreclosures. How these foreclosures will impact the mortgage lending industry has not yet been determined, but for many lenders a mortgage impairment policy will soften the blow.
Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and Ginnie Mae all require their lenders to purchase mortgage errors and omissions coverage, which is often included in a mortgage impairment policy. Due to widespread damage caused by Katrina and the likelihood of uninsured damage, the mortgage impairment policy can have value well beyond compliance with the secondary mortgage market's requirements for insurance.
A mortgage impairment policy is a hybrid insurance product that provides both first-party mortgage holder's interest coverage and third-party mortgage errors and omissions coverage. The first party coverage protects the lender from its loss of mortgage holder interest due to uninsured physical damage to mortgaged property. Basic coverage protects against "required perils" or those causes of loss that the lender requires the borrower to purchase to insure the mortgaged property.
For example, most mortgage documents require the borrower to obtain and maintain fire coverage on the mortgaged property, so as a required peril, a basic mortgage impairment policy would protect the lender if a mortgaged property was damaged by fire and if the borrower did not have the required insurance. Some insurers also offer a broader coverage that protects the lender from damage to collateral caused by causes of loss "not required" to be insured in the mortgage documents. Such coverage often extends to flood and earthquake.
If a mortgaged property is not located in a Special Flood Hazard Area (Flood Zones A and V), lenders typically do not require the borrower to obtain flood coverage. Hurricane Katrina caused flood damage to many properties outside of the Special Flood Hazard Area, so the broader MI coverage may become beneficial to the lenders who chose to purchase it.
The extent to which lenders will be able to recover losses under their mortgage impairment policies depends on many factors, some of which are: 1) the broadness of the coverage they purchased; 2) their understanding of the policy terms, conditions and coverages; 3) their internal guidelines and compliance with procedures for verifying and maintaining insurance on mortgaged properties; and 4) their ability to gather appropriate documentation and properly submit claim information to their insurance carriers.
Each lender who is expecting to benefit from their mortgage impairment policy must at least have a basic understanding of how their policy addresses the following:
* Is coverage provided on a "per mortgage," "per occurrence" or annual aggregate basis and which limit of insurance applies to each?
* Does the policy provide coverage for mortgaged property damaged by flood, either if the property was required to be protected by flood insurance or if it was not located in a special flood hazard area and flood insurance was not required?
* Does the policy provide coverage if the borrower had insurance coverage, but the limits of insurance were inadequate to cover the entire damage? What if the borrower's insurer is unable to make a full claim payment because they become insolvent?
* What are the time constraints for submitting mortgage impairment claims to the insurance carrier?
* Will the insurer require the lender to foreclosure on the property or will they approve a "deed in lieu of foreclosure" or other workout method that will allow the lender to reduce their expenses?
* How will the value of the damaged property be determined? Is sale required?
* Does coverage extend to mortgages the lender services for others? To what extent will secondary mortgage markets want to be involved in the foreclosure process and how will they benefit from any insurance recovery available to the lender?
Considering that many of the borrower forbearance programs are nearing an end, now is the time for lenders to obtain answers to these important questions and to develop a strategy for recovering from their insurance. Although it might take months, and possibly years, for all the issues related to damage caused by Katrina to be resolved, advance planning and communication with their insurance agents, brokers, consultants and underwriters as well as their in house financial managers will help lenders minimize the overall impact of Katrina.
(c) 2006 Mortgage Servicing News and SourceMedia, Inc. All Rights Reserved. http://www.mortgageservicingnews.com http://www.sourcemedia.com