Editorial: The Cramdown Question

Several years ago, creditors won an important legislative victory when Congress tightened bankruptcy laws, restricting the ability of consumers to discharge debt and protecting mortgage lenders from "cramdowns." The mortgage lenders' secured exemption from having mortgage amounts reduced was preserved.

But now the issue of cramdowns has surfaced again, and it could have a big impact on mortgage servicers, especially with a rising tide of defaults forcing them to manage more bankruptcy cases.

The Home Ownership and Mortgage Equity Protection Act of 2007, pending before congressional committees in Washington right now, would allow judges to reduce, or cram down, the amount of secured debt on primary residential mortgage loans. Mortgage Bankers Association chairman-elect David Kittle, in testimony before a House committee, argued that such a measure will cost consumers money in the long run by restricting the flow of capital into home loans and making mortgages more expensive. The bill, he warned, chips away at the security created on home mortgages.

In the past, legislators and courts -- with a few notable exceptions -- have respected the security instrument of a home mortgage and declined to tamper with it, reasoning that mortgages for homebuyers are cheaper and more widely available in America than anywhere else in the world for a reason. Tampering with the security instrument didn't seem like a good idea.

But today's subprime meltdown, and a rising tide of foreclosure-related hard-luck stories, has shifted the tide of public opinion and political sentiment in the direction of greater consumer protection. There's a good chance that the Home Ownership and Mortgage Equity Protection Act of 2007 will never become law. But that doesn't mean servicers won't be under pressure from elected officials and consumer groups, at both the state and federal levels, to cut a break for troubled homeowners. California's governor recently persuaded the largest servicers in his state to help streamline loan modifications for borrowers, keeping some at their initial interest rate after their payments were scheduled to reset. In order to ward off more draconian measures from Congress, lenders and their representatives would be well advised to make every effort they can to accommodate seriously delinquent borrowers if it is permissible under pooling and servicing agreements and will keep them in their homes.

(c) 2007 Mortgage Servicing News and SourceMedia, Inc. All Rights Reserved. http://www.mortgageservicingnews.com/ http://www.sourcemedia.com/

Next in News ►