Litigation Worries

If you haven't had a "litigation checkup" recently, now might be a good time to think about having internal and external attorneys take a look at your loan servicing practices. Nobody likes having lawyers meddle with established business practices, but the case of Fairbanks Capital demonstrates just how much trouble you could be in if politicians, regulators and, perhaps worst of all, class-action attorneys set their sights on your company.

Congress is considering legislation that could increase penalties for loan servicers that run afoul of regulatory requirements or loan documents. News media are expanding the definition of "predatory lending" to include aggressive collection practices. And the plaintiffs counsel industry smells blood. You can bet, especially in the subprimne mortgage world, that lenders will face increasing scrutiny of their customer service and collection practices.

The original furor over "predatory lending" focused on the misdeeds of only a few loan originators. It's not hard to see how a few horror stories, involving borrowers who lost their homes because of reckless or negligent loan servicing, could stir up a hornet's nest of angry homeowners, consumer activists and regulators. That would be bad news for the loan servicing industry.

It's not good enough to make sure that borrowers get a fair shake most of the time. A few problems with your portfolio could land you in the kind of mess that Fairbanks finds itself in today. In our judgment, loan servicers should place renewed emphasis on compliance and quality control to minimize their risk of investigation and litigation.

It's not easy managing a loan portfolio in an environment of rapid portfolio churning and increasing regulatory scrutiny. Add a bunch of mergers and acquisitions to the mix, and it's easy to see how some lenders have faced "integration issues" in these times. Then there's always pressure from the corporate parent company to reduce costs. Small wonder some borrowers are unsatisfied with the customer service they have been getting.

But customer satisfaction is about more than just paving the way for increased portfolio retention when homeowners refinance. Bad decisions in the call center could lead to lawsuits down the line. We hope the industry will be on guard against this peril.

Copyright 2003 Thomson Media Inc. All Rights Reserved. http://www.thomsonmedia.com http://www.mortgageservicingnews.com