Home Builders Are Upset with FHA's 'Credit Watch' Actions

The mortgage lending affiliates of homebuilders are starting to get clipped under the Federal Housing Administration's Credit Watch program and they want the agency to change the default standards so that they are not penalized for concentrating on home purchase loans.

In a letter to FHA commissioner John Weicher, the National Association of Home Builders argue that the early default rate (loans 90 days or more past due) on FHA loans is declining because of the heavy volume of refinancings over the past years.

Home purchase loans generally have higher default rates than seasoned refinanced loans. And the default rate on loans to first-time homebuyers is much higher.

As a result, several homebuilders are very close to having their FHA lending privileges suspended under the Credit Watch program.

Earlier this year, the Department of Housing and Urban Development released a new list of Credit Watch actions, which included the suspension of a Charlotte, N.C., branch office of DHI Mortgage Co., which is an affiliate of the nation's largest homebuilder, D.R. Horton Inc., Arlington, Texas. DHI Mortgage, based in Austin, Texas, did not return phone calls.

NAHB is recommending that the FHA create separate default standards for refinancings and purchase mortgages so that builders are not penalized for providing FHA financing to minority and low- and moderate-income families.

"Otherwise, HUD will be conducting investigations and inquiries that discourage builders and their lending subsidiaries from selling homes and making loans to the very group that President Bush has targeted for increased homeownership," NAHB says in the letter to the FHA commissioner. HUD declined to comment.

Under the Credit Watch program, the FHA can suspend a branch office when the default/claim ratio for new originations over the first two years is twice the national average. The DHI Mortgage Charlotte branch has an early default/claim ratio that is more than four times the 2.11% national average. Overall, DHI Mortgage has a 2.04% early default/claims rate, according to HUD data.

Copyright 2004 Thomson Media Inc. All Rights Reserved. http://www.thomsonmedia.com http://www.mortgageservicingnews.com