HUD Targeting Builder Abuses Again

The Department of Housing and Urban Development is taking another stab at preventing abuses by builders and others that entice consumers with bogus discounts that require them to use affiliated title and mortgage companies. HUD issued a proposal to address the issue of "required use" under its Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act rulemaking authority. The comment period ends September 1. "It is our intent to keep an open mind on how to approach this vexing question over what is, and what is not, required use," said HUD assistant secretary David Stevens. In early 2009, the National Association of Home Builders sued to block HUD from enforcing a newly adopted RESPA rule that banned builders from offering discounts to homebuyers that use affiliated settlement service providers. It is not uncommon for builders to offer borrowers cash discounts or upgrades on a house if the buyer agrees to use affiliated vendors. RESPA issues occur when the builder charges the consumer higher settlement costs (including the rate) than other non-affiliated providers. "HUD has received complaints that some homebuyers are committing to use a builder's affiliated mortgage lender without sufficient time to research their contracts or to comparison shop," HUD says in its proposal.