Mortgage Servicing Dispute Heads to Court

First Catholic Federal Credit Union, Taylor, Mich., has filed suit in federal court to terminate a mortgage servicing contract it has with CUSO Mortgage, claiming CUSO violated its agreement with the credit union by, among other things, failing to file Form 1098s with the Internal Revenue Service for its borrowers. "That's only one of the allegations," said Charles Holzman, a Southfield, Mich., attorney for Holzman Ritter & Corkery, which is representing the credit union in the case. He said the CU hopes to resolve the dispute with a minimum of public attention. In its lawsuit, the $146 million First Catholic claims it should not have to pay a 2% (of outstanding principal balance) termination fee for the servicing contract because the company (a subsidiary of Wescom Central CU of Pasadena, Calif.) failed to live up to the contract. The 2% termination fee is currently being held in an escrow account. Among other things, the suit claims that CUSO Mortgage, which provides servicing for as many as 100 credit unions, has failed to pay delinquent taxes for previous tax years. First Catholic claims its employees have had to perform many of the servicing chores that CUSO was supposed to handle. It is asking the court to release the 2% payment, and to order the transfer of the mortgages to a new servicer hired by the credit union. Representatives from CUSO Mortgage declined to comment.