Using Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data, it isn’t very hard to show that a lender is not serving certain areas in their community.
If those areas have high concentrations of minorities, the chances of being sued for a fair lending violation just increased due to a new rule issued by the Department of the Housing and Urban Development.
The final rule allows government and civil rights attorneys to use statistics to prove discriminatory lending practices. Under this “
“We know that HMDA data for virtually all lenders shows some disparity correlated with race and national origin,” said Paul Hancock, a partner at K&L Gates.
On average minorities have lower credit scores than whites. So the use of credit scores can have a disproportionate impact on minorities. But it “doesn’t mean it’s discriminatory,” Hancock said. The HUD rule makes exceptions for practices with a “legally sufficient justification.”
Justice Department attorneys have used this legal standard for many years to bring fair lending cases against banks for failing to reach out to minority and low-income neighborhoods. And U.S. district courts have ruled in favor of plaintiffs in disparate impact in cases.
“Through the issuance of this rule, HUD is reaffirming its commitment to enforcing the Fair Housing Act in a consistent and uniform manner,” said HUD secretary Shaun Donovan. “This will ensure the continued strength of one of the most important tools for exposing and ending housing discrimination.”
HUD has the authority to investigate fair housing complaints and bring charges against lenders.
HUD has issued the rule just as the Supreme Court is considering whether to review a disparate impact case involving the Township of Mount Holly, N.J., and residents of a minority neighborhood who want to stop a redevelopment project.
“In the absence of guidance from the court, pressure continues on the residential mortgage lending industry to manage end numbers, which may assist in avoiding disparate-impact liability but runs counter to the purpose of the Fair Housing Act,” the joint industry brief says.
-
The publicly traded title holding companies all had stronger earnings as the mortgage market improved from one year prior.
45m ago -
One in every 37 residential properties nationwide had a loan-to-value ratio of 125% or greater to begin the year, according to a new report.
1h ago -
There's temporary leeway on formal compliance with replacement-cost value requirements in order to sort out insurer concerns with a recent re-emphasis on them.
1h ago -
Max Levchin, CEO of the buy now/pay later lender, said recent tests show young adults prefer interacting with intelligent chatbots over phone-based agents, but the company doesn't foresee major cost savings from generative AI for a few more years.
3h ago -
Test your knowledge of the biggest mortgage headlines of the week. No. 2 pencil not required!
9h ago -
The San Diego company was back in the black with a net income of $28.5 million in the first quarter of 2024, up from a net loss of $93 million the previous quarter.
May 9