Foreclosed Ohio mansion to be auctioned, but with a catch

Home shoppers may soon have a chance to snag an Upper Arlington, Ohio, mansion for about half its value.

The 14,000-square-foot home, at 4860 Oldbridge Drive, will be auctioned in a few weeks with a starting bid of $1.4 million, less than half of what it last sold for.

The offer comes with a catch: Because the home is a foreclosure, prospective buyers can't see the inside or even step foot on the property.

"It's a considerable risk for somebody to agree to spend $1.4 million on something they can't look at," acknowledged Rich Kruse, managing partner of Gryphon USA, the auction company handling the sale for the lender, Fifth Third Bank.

"But at the same time, the trade-off is you could potentially be getting this house for 50 cents on the dollar. Some investors may have that appetite for risk."

While a handful of million-dollar homes were foreclosed upon during the housing crash, Kruse is unaware of any central Ohio home of this value entering foreclosure.

"I've been doing this for 20 years, and it's the largest one I've heard of, the most expensive one I've heard of," he said.

Built in 1972, the Tudor-style home includes six bedrooms, 5 full bathrooms and 2 half baths in 9,189 square feet. A finished lower level brings the size to 14,000 square feet.

In addition, the home includes a pool, a pool house, a gazebo and a 12-car showroom with a loft. The lot measures almost an acre in size.

The property belongs to Jeffrey Hosking, 49, president of Power Marketing Direct, which licenses dealers to sell mattresses and furniture.

Hosking, who could not be reached for comment, paid $2.86 million for the home in April 2005.

After a string of legal and financial troubles, which included a 2013 stop in jail for contempt of court, Hosking's home was foreclosed upon by Fifth Third in 2015.

Even though the home is being auctioned privately, instead of through the conventional route of a sheriff sale, most of the same rules apply. That means access to the home is prohibited because the title remains with Hosking.

Other than some landscaping neglect, the home appears from the street in sound condition.

Bob Sorrell, a veteran Upper Arlington real-estate agent who is familiar with the home, said the lot alone might be worth $700,000.

"I don't think there will be any problem with that property selling at $1.8 million or possibly over $2 million," Sorrell said. "Any bid of $1.7 million should be favorable to the purchaser, even if they had to incur $300,000 or $400,000 in improvement costs."

The Franklin County Auditor values the home at $2.586 million while Zillow estimates its value at $3.272 million.

Buyers can weigh in with their own bids at www.gryphonusa.com from 9 a.m. Aug. 28 to 1 p.m. Sept. 5.

The winning bidder's financial obligation doesn't end with the mortgage. Taxes on the home are $59,856 a year.

Tribune Content Agency
Foreclosures REO Fifth Third Ohio
MORE FROM NATIONAL MORTGAGE NEWS