Once-hot Toronto housing hits deep freeze as new rules bite
The only thing that might be colder than Toronto in January is the city's housing market.
While the bleak mid-winter is never the best time to sell a home in Canada, a string of open houses in the country's largest city were chillingly empty on a recent Saturday afternoon. Tougher mortgage rules went into effect on Jan. 1 just as higher interest rates began to bite, and the market's on edge, waiting to see if a downturn that began last year will accelerate under the added pressure.
"Lots of people are sitting on the sidelines waiting or hoping that prices would fall," John Pasalis, president of Toronto-based Realosophy Realty Inc., said in a phone interview. "I don't expect to see a rapid increase in prices or a big turnaround this year."
Toronto's housing market has cooled for seven months, with prices falling and listings surging. The market has begun to buckle under a raft of measures to curb prices that were soaring at a 20% clip a year ago and saddling Canadians with debt, part of a global real estate boom that's swept cities from Hong Kong to New York.
The latest move requires that even people with a 20% down payment, who don't need mortgage insurance, prove that they can make payments at much higher rates. The so-called stress tests, which already exist for insured mortgages, will be calculated at a rate of at least 2 percentage points above the contracted rate.
And those rates are going up. The country's central bank increased its overnight target rate three times in the past year, to 1.25%. The country's big banks have followed suit, nudging mortgage rates to a four-year high.
Reality is sinking in as buyers update their pre-approved mortgages at the higher rates, Dawna Borg, a sales representative at Remax Premier Inc., said in an email.
"They seem to feel defeated," she said. "They feel they will fail the stress tests and they will be forced out of the market."
Analysts at Macquarie Capital Markets Canada Ltd. say the new stress tests and mortgage-rate hikes in Canada's environment of "hyper-leveraging" will have a more severe impact than policymakers expect. The rules alone will reduce purchasing power by as much as 17%, the bank said in a report. Add in the mortgage-rate increase and that number jumps to about 23%.
The Magnelli family is feeling the effects. Mom Loredana Magnelli has saved for a few years to help her two kids, age 30 and 26, put together down payments to purchase apartments in Toronto. Their price point of about C$300,000 ($243,000) each seemed like a viable opportunity two years ago. Now, that seems impossible.
"When you're looking at a C$400,000 to C$450,000 mortgage and your interest rate is going to be higher, that's huge money," Magnelli said. She considered adding another mortgage to her own house to help get her kids their dream homes, but ultimately decided against it. They've put a stop to their search for now in hopes that home prices will fall to more affordable levels.
"It's pretty frustrating," she said. "My son is 30. He'd like to have a place of his own."
Amid the crunch in single-family homes, Tim Syrianos, president of the Toronto Real Estate Board, has seen a "tremendous spike" in interest for more affordable housing types like condominiums, townhouses and semi-detached homes. While the city's detached-home segment tumbled in the second half of 2017, condominium sales rose at a double-digit pace.
Activity is also seeping out into surrounding suburbs that are near public transit and far more affordable than the city core, real-estate agents say.
And just when you think the Canadian housing market is down for the count it tends to find a second wind. Vancouver's housing market plunged for five months after policymakers introduced a foreign-buyers tax in 2016 but has been recovering steadily since last year. Toronto's economy meanwhile is booming with the unemployment rate falling to 4.3% in December from 5.5% a year ago even as the city remains a magnet for immigrants.
Syrianos's big worry isn't a cooling market but the lack of supply. "If supply continues to be as tight as it is, we will see double-digit increase in values."
Two of his clients for example were looking to buy a new house after having a baby but no longer qualify for a bigger mortgage under the new stress tests. They're renovating instead.
"You're creating a heated renovation segment of the market and you're stifling supply," Syrianos says. "It just leads to more values going up faster than they should and making it harder for the average Canadian to buy a home."
Ultimately, policymakers and brokers alike want steady, incremental home price gains. Double-digit price growth was volatile and dangerous, said Simeon Papailias, co-founder of the Real Estate Center, real estate management company. The new stress test will help make sure "that we don't have unqualified people creating bidding wars," he said in a phone interview.
The Toronto Real Estate Board is forecasting sales of 85,000 to 95,000 homes this year, down from 92,394 last year. Prices are forecast at C$800,000 to C$850,000, the midpoint of which would be up slightly from the C$822,681 average recorded in 2017. Prices rose almost 13% last year, the board said in its annual market outlook on Tuesday.
January numbers are due in the next several days but the real test will likely come as the spring selling season gets underway.
"Sellers are looking for the money they were getting in May, and that's not a reality, it's not going to happen," Papailias, at the Real Estate Center, said.